A lot of people start researching breast reduction with one worry in mind: “Do I even qualify?”
Here’s the honest answer—there isn’t a universal cup-size cutoff. Cup letters vary wildly between brands and aren’t used as medical criteria. Surgeons evaluate symptoms, proportions, and tissue weight, not the label on your bra.
At Dr. David Liland’s Dallas practice, candidacy is about comfort and function first. If breast size is driving daily pain or limiting activity, you deserve a straightforward evaluation—no guessing games.
Guide
- There’s No “One Size Fits All”
- How Surgeons Actually Decide
- The Schnur Sliding Scale (and Why It’s Not the Whole Story)
- “My Cup Size Isn’t Huge—Do I Still Qualify?”
- What Approval Usually Requires
- Why Patients Say It’s Worth It
- The Bottom Line
There’s No “One Size Fits All”
Cup sizes are inconsistent from brand to brand, and many people wear the wrong size to begin with, which is why surgeons don’t lean on letters when making medical decisions. Instead, they look at your frame, posture, shoulder grooving, skin issues, and how much breast tissue is contributing to symptoms.
How Surgeons Actually Decide
During a consultation, your surgeon will document problems linked to heavy breasts, such as:
- Chronic neck, back, or shoulder pain
- Rashes/skin irritation beneath the fold
- Grooving from bra straps
- Numbness/tingling or posture changes
- Exercise limitations and activity avoidance
These are the very symptoms medical societies and insurers associate with symptomatic macromastia, the condition breast reduction treats. If conservative measures (PT, supportive bras, medications) haven’t helped, surgery is often considered medically necessary.
The Schnur Sliding Scale (and Why It’s Not the Whole Story)
Some insurers still reference the Schnur Sliding Scale, which compares your body-surface area with the estimated grams of tissue to be removed. It’s used to decide whether a case meets their internal threshold for “medical necessity.” But even insurer policies acknowledge the numbers vary by plan, and professional societies have questioned using this chart as the sole approval criterion.
Translation: symptoms and functional impact matter—sometimes more than a number on a table.
Practical takeaway: If you’ve got real, documented symptoms, you may still qualify even when the predicted removal doesn’t land neatly on a chart.
“My Cup Size Isn’t Huge—Do I Still Qualify?”
Possibly, yes. Smaller-framed patients can experience significant pain with what looks like a “moderate” cup size. Because approval is tied to functional problems (and supported by exam findings and photographs), people across a range of sizes can be appropriate candidates.
If insurance ultimately won’t cover a large reduction, a smaller-volume reduction or reshaping can still improve balance and comfort. That decision is made together after an in-person exam.
What Approval Usually Requires (If You’re Using Insurance)
Most plans ask for:
- A surgeon’s letter of medical necessity describing symptoms and failed conservative care,
- Photos and exam notes, and
- Sometimes, a predicted tissue-removal estimate aligned with their policy language.
Pre-authorization timelines vary, but two to four weeks is common; appeals are often successful when more documentation is added.
Why Patients Say It’s Worth It
Long-term research shows high satisfaction after reduction mammaplasty and durable relief of pain and activity limits—regardless of the exact amount of tissue removed. In several studies, more than 95% of patients said they’d do it again.
The Bottom Line
There isn’t a magic cup size that “qualifies” you. What matters is how your breasts affect your life. If you’re dealing with daily discomfort, limited workouts, or clothing that never fits right, you don’t have to live that way.
Book a consultation with Dr. Liland in Dallas. You’ll get a clear, respectful assessment, guidance on documentation if insurance may apply, and a plan that aims for comfort and natural balance.
Disclaimer
Please note: All materials on the Site, such as text, treatments, outcomes, photographs and images and any other material provided on the Site are for information purposes only and are not a substitute for professional medical advice. Always seek the advice of your physician or another qualified health provider with any questions you may have regarding treatments. Never disregard professional medical advice or delay in seeking it because of something you have read on this Site.
Though the content of this blog has been carefully prepared, the author of this content is not a medical doctor and the content has not been reviewed by a Board-Certified Plastic Surgeon.
Unless specifically stated, patients referred to in this blog have not received a liposuction procedure from Dr. Liland. This blog does not endorse the work of any doctors or surgeons mentioned. Stories relating to patients’ personal experiences of liposuction procedures should be treated as anecdotal only.
Any application of the material provided is at the reader’s discretion and his, her, or their responsibility.